Skip to content
In The Kibble
My dogs
COMPARE

Brand vs Brand

The dog food brands people weigh against each other, compared on what is actually in the bag: protein, fat, starch, calories, ingredients and recall history. Kibble against kibble, from the recipes we review, with nothing taken from the brands' own marketing.

Acana vs Orijen Protein 30% vs 39%, as fed 23 vs 14 kibble recipes Blue Buffalo vs Purina Protein 28% vs 27%, as fed 108 vs 105 kibble recipes Hill's vs Royal Canin Protein 21% vs 25%, as fed 66 vs 86 kibble recipes Purina vs Hill's Protein 27% vs 21%, as fed 105 vs 66 kibble recipes Royal Canin vs Purina Protein 25% vs 27%, as fed 86 vs 105 kibble recipes Blue Buffalo vs Hill's Protein 28% vs 21%, as fed 108 vs 66 kibble recipes Blue Buffalo vs Royal Canin Protein 28% vs 25%, as fed 108 vs 86 kibble recipes Iams vs Purina Protein 25% vs 27%, as fed 21 vs 105 kibble recipes Pedigree vs Purina Protein 23% vs 27%, as fed 15 vs 105 kibble recipes Iams vs Pedigree Protein 25% vs 23%, as fed 21 vs 15 kibble recipes Eukanuba vs Royal Canin Protein 26% vs 25%, as fed 28 vs 86 kibble recipes Blue Buffalo vs Taste of the Wild Protein 28% vs 29%, as fed 108 vs 16 kibble recipes Merrick vs Blue Buffalo Protein 30% vs 28%, as fed 58 vs 108 kibble recipes Wellness vs Blue Buffalo Protein 31% vs 28%, as fed 67 vs 108 kibble recipes Nutro vs Blue Buffalo Protein 24% vs 28%, as fed 47 vs 108 kibble recipes Natural Balance vs Blue Buffalo Protein 25% vs 28%, as fed 37 vs 108 kibble recipes Rachael Ray Nutrish vs Blue Buffalo Protein 25% vs 28%, as fed 12 vs 108 kibble recipes Diamond vs Taste of the Wild Protein 25% vs 29%, as fed 27 vs 16 kibble recipes Canidae vs Taste of the Wild Protein 27% vs 29%, as fed 26 vs 16 kibble recipes Orijen vs Taste of the Wild Protein 39% vs 29%, as fed 14 vs 16 kibble recipes Victor vs Diamond Protein 28% vs 25%, as fed 21 vs 27 kibble recipes Fromm vs Acana Protein 26% vs 30%, as fed 39 vs 23 kibble recipes Fromm vs Orijen Protein 26% vs 39%, as fed 39 vs 14 kibble recipes Instinct vs Orijen Protein 31% vs 39%, as fed 38 vs 14 kibble recipes Nulo vs Orijen Protein 30% vs 39%, as fed 61 vs 14 kibble recipes Open Farm vs Orijen Protein 29% vs 39%, as fed 29 vs 14 kibble recipes Merrick vs Wellness Protein 30% vs 31%, as fed 58 vs 67 kibble recipes Nutro vs Purina Protein 24% vs 27%, as fed 47 vs 105 kibble recipes Iams vs Blue Buffalo Protein 25% vs 28%, as fed 21 vs 108 kibble recipes Pedigree vs Blue Buffalo Protein 23% vs 28%, as fed 15 vs 108 kibble recipes Eukanuba vs Purina Protein 26% vs 27%, as fed 28 vs 105 kibble recipes Eukanuba vs Hill's Protein 26% vs 21%, as fed 28 vs 66 kibble recipes Iams vs Hill's Protein 25% vs 21%, as fed 21 vs 66 kibble recipes Nutro vs Hill's Protein 24% vs 21%, as fed 47 vs 66 kibble recipes Wellness vs Hill's Protein 31% vs 21%, as fed 67 vs 66 kibble recipes Rachael Ray Nutrish vs Purina Protein 25% vs 27%, as fed 12 vs 105 kibble recipes Natural Balance vs Purina Protein 25% vs 27%, as fed 37 vs 105 kibble recipes Canidae vs Blue Buffalo Protein 27% vs 28%, as fed 26 vs 108 kibble recipes Fromm vs Blue Buffalo Protein 26% vs 28%, as fed 39 vs 108 kibble recipes Diamond vs Blue Buffalo Protein 25% vs 28%, as fed 27 vs 108 kibble recipes Instinct vs Blue Buffalo Protein 31% vs 28%, as fed 38 vs 108 kibble recipes Solid Gold vs Blue Buffalo Protein 27% vs 28%, as fed 28 vs 108 kibble recipes NutriSource vs Blue Buffalo Protein 26% vs 28%, as fed 63 vs 108 kibble recipes Authority vs Blue Buffalo Protein 26% vs 28%, as fed 22 vs 108 kibble recipes Simply Nourish vs Blue Buffalo Protein 28% vs 28%, as fed 25 vs 108 kibble recipes Merrick vs Taste of the Wild Protein 30% vs 29%, as fed 58 vs 16 kibble recipes Earthborn Holistic vs Taste of the Wild Protein 27% vs 29%, as fed 23 vs 16 kibble recipes Victor vs Taste of the Wild Protein 28% vs 29%, as fed 21 vs 16 kibble recipes Canidae vs Merrick Protein 27% vs 30%, as fed 26 vs 58 kibble recipes Wellness vs Nutro Protein 31% vs 24%, as fed 67 vs 47 kibble recipes Wellness vs Fromm Protein 31% vs 26%, as fed 67 vs 39 kibble recipes Merrick vs Fromm Protein 30% vs 26%, as fed 58 vs 39 kibble recipes NutriSource vs Fromm Protein 26% vs 26%, as fed 63 vs 39 kibble recipes Open Farm vs Fromm Protein 29% vs 26%, as fed 29 vs 39 kibble recipes Acana vs Taste of the Wild Protein 30% vs 29%, as fed 23 vs 16 kibble recipes Zignature vs Orijen Protein 29% vs 39%, as fed 29 vs 14 kibble recipes Zignature vs Acana Protein 29% vs 30%, as fed 29 vs 23 kibble recipes Nulo vs Acana Protein 30% vs 30%, as fed 61 vs 23 kibble recipes Instinct vs Acana Protein 31% vs 30%, as fed 38 vs 23 kibble recipes Stella & Chewy's vs Orijen Protein 30% vs 39%, as fed 48 vs 14 kibble recipes Now Fresh vs Orijen Protein 26% vs 39%, as fed 24 vs 14 kibble recipes Go! Solutions vs Orijen Protein 25% vs 39%, as fed 28 vs 14 kibble recipes

Want two specific recipes side by side instead? Use the comparison tool with any foods from our reviews.

Keep In The Know,
Know What's In The Bowl

The In the Kibble newsletter. Useful emails for dog owners: what we find inside dog food, how to feed well, and a heads-up when a food is recalled.
DOUBLE OPT-IN // ONE CLICK TO STOP // NEVER SHARED